To round out my criticism posts, I’m including one from August 2018, Constructive Criticism vs BS. Do you know the difference? They’re both criticism. But one is a gem and the other just stinks of BS. The last two posts on criticism would not be complete with highlighting the difference between the two. One can really help you grow as an artist and the other, well…what do you normally do with BS? Ignore it, bury it, toss it out with the trash, try not to step in it…you get the picture. Check out the repost here, which I’ve posted in its entirety, or you can check out the original post here.

Constructive Criticism versus BS

Know When To Pay Attention

Do you know the difference between constructive criticism and BS? It’s understandable why new artists hesitate to put their work out there for people to see. Social media is especially full of opinionated jackasses who have no business or basis for their comments. These are the people who offer unsolicited criticism and worthless advice (worthless because they have little to no artistic background themselves). Still, it’s hurtful to read some of the cruel things they say. It puts artists in a tough spot. Generally, we artists are by nature much more sensitive souls and we can tend to take to heart the mean things that people say. My advice would be to somehow magically grow a thicker skin. After all, if you intend to be an artist, it’s almost a requirement. Easier said than done, I know. But if you can learn how to tell the difference between constructive criticism and the mass quantities of BS, you might just survive to paint, sculpt, or draw another day.

Don’t listen to the BS. It isn’t worth your time. (Photo Credit: 123RF.com Copyright : STUDIO GRAND WEB)

Let’s start with the BS.

People are so willing to spout off their opinions. They think nothing of slamming people and things they know very little about. If the person commenting can only tell you that your work sucks and no terminology as to why they think it is lacking, it’s BS. If you were to ask them how they think you could improve it and they aren’t be able to tell you, it’s BS. Anybody with any background in art would be able to elaborate. If the person spouting off is not an artist, it’s BS. Why would you listen to anyone who isn’t an expert, or at the very least more experienced than you are?

When you receive constructive criticism, take the time to seriously consider your work from their point of view. (Photo Credit: 123RF.com Copyright : Ion Chiosea)

On to the Positive

Constructive criticism is exactly what it sounds like. It’s criticism, but with a good dose of constructive advice. The person who offers constructive criticism will know what they’re talking about. Their comments will point out precisely where your artwork is lacking and how you might go about correcting it. It’s really that simple.

As far as the BS goes, let it roll off your back. Use the block feature on social media if necessary. However, even constructive criticism may sting a little. But I encourage you to take a step back and honestly reevaluate your work through new eyes. Look at it as if it weren’t your own work and try to see what the person giving the critique sees. At the very least, you’ll open your mind to a new point of view. At best, your artwork will improve. And isn’t that what we all want?

Further Reading:

Criticism

Ya Gotta Have a Thick Skin